With Den Automation facing immanent demise, I’ve been looking at alternatives.

I came across the Shelly 1 relay, quite by accident, whilst looking at some Sonoff stuff. It immediately piqued my interest, mostly because it taught me that I didn’t know anything about lighting circuits in the UK.

I’ve installed my fair share of lighting fixtures during the renovation of my home and whilst I was astonished at the number of connections in a ceiling rose, I never really took any time to investigate why.

Image result for ceiling rose wiring
Typical ceiling rose wiring arrangement in UK home

I had made my own attempts at automating lighting when I first moved in. This was a crude affair, which involved putting a Sonoff Basic relay in between the rose and bulb.

Whilst functional, the downside was that flipping the physical switch turned the relay off. Bye, bye, remote switching.

This is where the Shelly 1 comes into play.

Shelly 1 Wi-Fi WLAN switching actuator 16 A SHELLY SHELLY 1
The Shelly 1 relay. Small, but powerful 🙂

I came across an excellent post, which explained how to connect the little unit to a UK ceiling rose, which is well worth checking out – https://gist.github.com/lordneon/aecf24035a4dc5e6b950977e37aeb930

Essentially, the Shelly 1 is connected to the permanent supply, so it’s always on, regardless of the physical switch. The Shelly is also connected to the physical switch, so it knows when it’s been flipped.

This means that the light can be turned on and off via an API *and* by the existing light switch! I immediately ordered some.

A Christmas tree of relays.

My order included two Sonoff Minis, but I choose the Shelly1 to begin with as it supports MQTT control out of the box (which bypasses the Shelly Cloud – local control all the way). I know the Minis have to be flashed with Tasmota firmware to support MQTT and I didn’t want to get distracted!

Installation

WARNING! Please don’t attempt anything related to mains electricity unless your confident in your ability. Always remember to isolate circuits from the fuse board before doing anything!! I am not responsible if anything happens.

Installation was very straight forward with the help of the excellent WAGO connectors. Following the diagram, I installed the Shelly 1.

Wiring Diagram
https://gist.github.com/lordneon/aecf24035a4dc5e6b950977e37aeb930
The Shelly 1 wired in!

Once I’d restored power from the fuse board, I went through the configuration process. This followed the standard pattern of connecting to the Shelly’s WiFi network, connecting to my own WiFi network and then entering the MQTT server address and credentials.

It worked first time!

I set it’s Switched Live mode to edge, so that means that any change in the physical switch will turn it on or off, perfect for my needs.

Adding the Shelly to my Home Assistant required the addition of an MQTT entity with the appropriate topics.

  - platform: mqtt
    name: "Shelly-1"
    state_topic: "shellies/shelly1-B8B728/relay/0"
    command_topic: "shellies/shelly1-B8B728/relay/0/command"
    payload_on: "on"
    payload_off: "off"   

I repeated the process on another light in my house.

This was installed into a standard plastic ceiling rose, but unfortunately the cover wouldn’t close due to the thickness of the Shelly.

As this is pretty unsightly, I’ve decided to find a nice ceiling rose with the space to hold the Shelly before I install any more.

I’m so happy with these, they are a perfect replacement for my defunct Den switches. I’ll be replacing all of Den’s switches with these Shelly 1s once I find a good rose.

Be sure to check out my YouTube channel.

15 responses

  1. Did you ever find a ceiling rose with room for the shelly?

    1. No, not a plastic one anyway. I’ve used a metal B&Q ceiling rose in my sitting room and that has plenty of room. I have a few ceiling roses I got from Made.com, which are metal, and I think they have room, but I’ve not had a chance to fit them yet! I’m using Wago connectors, and they take up more space too.

  2. Hi
    Thanks for the post. I am also currently looking for a suitable ceiling rose to fit the shelly1.
    I bought the largest of the white plastic ones from Screwfix but they are also too small – 3.5″ at the base.

    Anyone have any good suggestions of ones to get would be good?

    thanks
    G

  3. Hey, I was having the same problem.

    For anyone’s benefit I found this one which I am using now – not as cheap as the plastic ones but at least it a manageable price:
    https://www.lampspares.co.uk/white-ceiling-plate-and-bracket-100mm-single-hole

    Hope it helps.

  4. Hey, I was having the same problem with fitting the shelly 1 into a standard ceiling rose.

    For anyone’s benefit I found this one which I am using now – not as cheap as the plastic ones but at least it a manageable price:
    https://www.lampspares.co.uk/white-ceiling-plate-and-bracket-100mm-single-hole

    Hope it helps.

  5. Thank you for posting this. Shelly seems like a better option than hacking about a sonoff basic or the larger size of the sonoff mini. Out of curiosity, what cable do you use? I have some solid core twin and earth but it’s hard to work with in short distances.

    1. I used some solid core and the exiting cables. I’ve use WAGO terminal blocks. Lots of wrestling with the pliers to make it all fit 🙂

  6. how did you wire up the ‘end of loop’ shelly 1 unit?

    1. Andy, sorry for the delay in replying. I be not had to install one at the end of the loop, but the wiring should be almost the same except the live and neutral don’t come out.

      This page shows the wiring you’d expect at the end of the radial
      circuit http://www.lightwiring.co.uk/tag/ceiling-rose/

      1. Thanks for the reply! Electrics aren’t my forte. Asling as it’s safe and works I’ll give it a go when my Shelly order turns up.

        Cheers

  7. What about QUINETIC switches instead?

  8. Hi Robert. I haven’t heard to this brand, but I googled and they look very similar to the Xiaomi Aqara switches. I have installed one of those – https://tomasmcguinness.com/2019/12/11/xiamo-aqara-wall-switch/ – it’s really reliable, it a little slow to react (down to the fact it’s Zigbee I think).
    Have you tried them? What do you think?

  9. […] The Shelly1 relays I installed were absolutely fantastic. I could not recommend them enough. Installing them requires some knowledge of wiring, but I had no issues installing them into several of the lights in my house. The pendant housing was the only real problem, so this time around I’ll have to find something a little larger. […]

  10. […] I’ve had a few Shelly 1 relays installed in my house and they brilliant. So brilliant in fact I’d sort of forgotten about them. But […]

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.